OK. I guess I had to eventually put this one in the pile. It's been discussed here to death. The cracks, the AP mix, James Guthrie, etc, etc.
If you've already posted about the title, and don't feel like going on and on again, just vote. It would be "too easy" to take this one at face value without comparing it to the vaulted 4.0 mix of AP. On the other hand, is it fair to compare it to the AP? Use your own judgement.
I feel it should be included in our list, so here it is. Have at it!