This AC/DC disc made me think of a Herman's Hermits song, if you can believe that! The song "A Must to Avoid".
UGH. What a mess. First off, I have to admit that I'm not a big AC/DC fan. I don't know all of the songs, but I do know (and like) some of the hits. However, I do know a well produced Blu-Ray disc from something that should have stayed as a regular DVD.
First off, the "concert" is far from that. Sure, there is video of the band on stage singing and playing, but unless I've lost my sense of audio, it's not what I was hearing through my audio system. What I was hearing was pure studio sound, with piped in applause between tracks. Now, the sound was pretty good, in fact, the surround mix was a bit on the aggressive side, with the lead guitar in the right channels, almost center right. Drums in the center left, vocals up front, so in some respects the surround mix is a bit above your normal "stage" presentation. However, when watching the video, it just reminds me of an old early MTV lip-sync concert video. Sad for a 2007 Blu-Ray release.
As far as the picture goes, it's purely ho-hum. When I watch an HD disc, I want to go "Oooo, Wow!". When I watched this one I went "Oh, Why?" Why is this released in HD when it looks like your average DVD. Granted, there are some interesting features. For some songs, you can select a single band member, and watch them (in 4:3) throughout the entire song, but it just magnifies the fact that you're not listening to the soundtrack of the concert!
The great songs still rock, however, and you can crank them up of course. If you do buy this disc, I would suggest playing it when you are NOT sitting down and watching it. Let it play while you're doing something 'round the house, and you should be cool. However, as a BD demo disc, this is not the first one in the stack!
Your results may vary, but my vote is a 3!