HiRez Poll Emerson Lake & Palmer - TARKUS [DVD-A/BDA]
- Thread starter JonUrban
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
Did. Did. Didn't.
No? How come? OK, I haven't played it in a while....but I recall enjoying it a bit.
leevitalone1
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
I won't spend a dime unless approved by the members here first!
I'd agree that SW didn't hit the target on this one. Or Trilogy. But it gets better after 4 or 5 drinks.
changed from 10 to a 9.
Years ago, when the DVDA came out I was sooo excited.
Playing it again now I can see the imperfect bass some have mentioned and some lack of visceral bite the original LP had.
Nit-picking perhaps, but in hindsight simply not a 10. Maybe the standards have been raised with bitchez brew and such.
still very happy we got it in surround though!
Years ago, when the DVDA came out I was sooo excited.
Playing it again now I can see the imperfect bass some have mentioned and some lack of visceral bite the original LP had.
Nit-picking perhaps, but in hindsight simply not a 10. Maybe the standards have been raised with bitchez brew and such.
still very happy we got it in surround though!
I'd agree that SW didn't hit the target on this one. Or Trilogy. But it gets better after 4 or 5 drinks.
Can't blame SW for Trilogy. That was JJ's work.
Btw tarkusnj's complaint on this thread wasn't 'lack of bass' per se -- it's was lack of *punch* in the low bass and bass. That's a different thing. You can a have plenty of bass in a mix, with it sounding loud but indistinct, or you can have a lot of bass, but also have upper bass/treble bite to give it 'punch' (definition).
Greg Lake's bass had lots of punch,, he loved him some treble in his Fender Jazz Bass sound. That should come through in a mix of this album.
(His treble love got crazy over the years; he experimented with Rickenbackers circa Trilogy, went back to J bass for BSS, tried a Zemeckis bass on tour...by the end of the 70s he was playing Alembics with the treble turned to 11, and sounded more like baritone guitar rather than a bass guitar)
Keith's Hammond sound has also been de-punched on SW's mix, but that seems to be from loss of that hard overdriven sound more than anything else. Maybe that was part of Eddy Offord's touch as much as Keith's here (he liked to print things 'hot'). Why SW chose not to emulate it, only he can say....
Greg Lake's bass had lots of punch,, he loved him some treble in his Fender Jazz Bass sound. That should come through in a mix of this album.
(His treble love got crazy over the years; he experimented with Rickenbackers circa Trilogy, went back to J bass for BSS, tried a Zemeckis bass on tour...by the end of the 70s he was playing Alembics with the treble turned to 11, and sounded more like baritone guitar rather than a bass guitar)
Keith's Hammond sound has also been de-punched on SW's mix, but that seems to be from loss of that hard overdriven sound more than anything else. Maybe that was part of Eddy Offord's touch as much as Keith's here (he liked to print things 'hot'). Why SW chose not to emulate it, only he can say....
I am probably in the minority here, but, having listened to TRILOGY 5.1 last night -- I really like the mix! There's a clarity in Greg Lake's vocals that really bring out what a great singer he was. . . .
YMMV, of course. Btw, is there a HI REZ poll on TRILOGY? A quick search didn't reveal it, but it probably hasn't been posted on in a while. . . .
edit: found it!
http://www.quadraphonicquad.com/for...er-trilogy-dvd-a-bda.20552/page-5#post-275949
I've been looking for over an hour to find this on Amazon or anywhere else I can find it. Does anyone know where I can find the Blu-ray Audio release of this?
uffeolby
300 Club - QQ All-Star
To my knowledge, there is no Blu-ray release of this - just a combo with CD and DVD-Audio.
uffeolby
300 Club - QQ All-Star
Ooops, just read the first post in this thread and it says:
The same 2012 5.1 mix is also available on Blu-Ray in the 2017 "Fanfare" box set.
Sure, it’s on Discogs in the $700 range.
There's at thread about it here:
https://www.quadraphonicquad.com/fo...-surround-mixes-on-blu-ray-coming-soon.23623/
It's remarkable in that it has the four essential ELP surround albums on a single blu ray disc.
yeah.. with "Trilogy" with a big authoring menu blunder!!!!
Was the Brain Salad Surgery ever released in CD/DVD combo like the other three? Thanks
No. Only on a DVD-Audio with a different mix. Many prefer the DVDA mix.
2001 DVD-A mix, FTW. One of my desert island discs...
For completeness's sake:
The BSS 2001 surround mix was rereleased on SACD in 2008. (The mix is the same, the mastering is a little different.)
Jakko's
Last edited:
Tarkus is a very highly rated Surround mixed disc. Look at the 9s and 10s logged! WOW!!!
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 24,360
Indeed. I just voted a 10!
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
