️ The Atmos mix is considerably quieter than the PCM stereo. But then, he was The Quiet One
‘Concert For George’ is the next release in the SDE Surround Series
- Thread starter 5.1 4 Life
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
️ The Atmos mix is considerably quieter than the PCM stereo. But then, he was The Quiet One
JediJoker
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
That will be down to the Dolby Dialogue Normalization metadata, discussed ad nauseam.
But then, he was The Quiet One
Last edited:
The -18 LKFS loudness requirement for Atmos pretty much always means it'll be a few dB quieter than accompanying stereo & 5.1 streams on the same disc.
How is the new Atmos mix on the BD-A vs streaming? My disc was shipped and hopefully arrives sometime next week.
i'm just at the tail end of a nearly 3hr long zoom thing i've been watching with the rhythm players of Steely Dan hosted by Steve Bailey with Victor Wooten, Chuck Rainey, Bernard Purdie, Steve Gadd, Anthony Jackson, Freddie Washington, Tom Barney, Keith Carlock, Dennis Chambers and Elliot Scheiner jumped in later on. then i'll give Concert For George a spin!
well nobody round here bought it hoping for a Surround sound extravaganza, right?
there's a lot of doubling up going on with replication of Front channel elements in the Rears. sometimes a polite ripple of applause is pushed towards the Rears, the Surround Backs seem to be mainly ambience. sometimes something feels like it might be going on elsewhere other than the Fronts but i'm not entirely convinced that certain something's not going on elsewhere as well. Something in the way it moves. or rather doesn't
sound quality's great and its a lovely concert, although having watched it before i think i'd really rather see what's happening again now as well i think.. from a Surround point of view its barely more immersive than the majority of concert videos and certainly isn't the kind of discrete Surround showcase of a 5.1 concert mix by say Elliot Scheiner. ah well, i'm still enjoying it, can never get enough of George's music
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 24,354
Adam, that's why I ordered the CRAFT RECORDINGS' 2 RBCD/2 BD~V set of the Concert for George a few weeks ago, anticipating that the SDE ATMOS release would be little more than you describe ..... double stereo, ambient and applause in rears.well nobody round here bought it hoping for a Surround sound extravaganza, right?
there's a lot of doubling up going on with replication of Front channel elements in the Rears. sometimes a polite ripple of applause is pushed towards the Rears, the Surround Backs seem to be mainly ambience. sometimes something feels like it might be going on elsewhere other than the Fronts but i'm not entirely convinced that certain something's not going on elsewhere as well. Something in the way it moves. or rather doesn't
sound quality's great and its a lovely concert, although having watched it before i think i'd really rather see what's happening again now as well i think.. from a Surround point of view its barely more immersive than the majority of concert videos and certainly isn't the kind of discrete Surround showcase of a 5.1 concert mix by say Elliot Scheiner. ah well, i'm still enjoying it, can never get enough of George's music
View attachment 89795
View attachment 89797
View attachment 89796
And the Craft Recording set is price wise on par with SDE's ATMOS release including s/h to the states. Worth investigating if you want visuals of both the Theatrical cut and COMPLETE CONCERT BD~V in stunning 1080p resolution and DTS~HD MA 5.1 sonics!
jefe1
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
What about the hype quote on SDE from the remixer on how adventurous he was on this remix?
Careful what you read on the internet.
Careful what you read on the internet.
The56Kid
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
Very disappointed to read that the mix is so sedate and non-immersive!well nobody round here bought it hoping for a Surround sound extravaganza, right?
there's a lot of doubling up going on with replication of Front channel elements in the Rears. sometimes a polite ripple of applause is pushed towards the Rears, the Surround Backs seem to be mainly ambience. sometimes something feels like it might be going on elsewhere other than the Fronts but i'm not entirely convinced that certain something's not going on elsewhere as well. Something in the way it moves. or rather doesn't
sound quality's great and its a lovely concert, although having watched it before i think i'd really rather see what's happening again now as well i think.. from a Surround point of view its barely more immersive than the majority of concert videos and certainly isn't the kind of discrete Surround showcase of a 5.1 concert mix by say Elliot Scheiner. ah well, i'm still enjoying it, can never get enough of George's music
View attachment 89795
View attachment 89797
View attachment 89796
Is the more immersive and “daring” Atmos mix an Easter egg or something, because it seems to be missing in action.
Way back in time, someone said try some
I tried some, now buy some, I bought some, oh oh oh
After a while when I had tried them, denied them
I opened my eyes...
Was this one supposed to have the slip case? I seem to remember it being release 6.5, so maybe not.
Paul @SDE said it wouldn't, its not one of the SDE series.
James_in_VA
Well-known Member
Please pardon my ignorance but is the Craft Recordings version different than the 2 CD/2 BD version sold on Amazon and reviewed here? I went to CR's site and there wasn't much of a description.
https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Concert-for-George-Blu-ray/19429/#Review
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 24,354
James, I can assure you the 2 RBCD/2 BD~V Theatrical cut/Full Concert [each concert version on a separate BD~V] are two different animals altogether than the stand alone BD~A [ATMOS/STEREO/no 5.1]!
Ironically, if you buy that 4 disc set from Deep Discount as we speak, with the 15% off coupon it's even cheaper than the stand alone SDE BD~A Atmos/Stereo version.
And the Craft Recordings 4 disc CONCERT FOR GEORGE set also comes in a nice sturdy slipcase with a 30 page booklet and IMO, IS THE BETTER DEAL!
https://www.deepdiscount.com/concer...ncert-for-george-2-blu-rays2-cds/888072030039
Last edited:
Oh crap, shit, fuck, I just can't.
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 24,354
Well at least you're still on CLOUD NINE, Markie with those spectacular DSOTM and TYA ATMOS releases ..... so in effect, TWO OUTTA THREE AIN'T BAD!
The TYA, absolute best of the year so far, for content and sound quality.Well at least you're still on CLOUD NINE, Markie with those spectacular DSOTM and TYA ATMOS releases ..... so in effect, TWO OUTTA THREE AIN'T BAD!
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 24,354
And the TYA inclusion of SO MANY audio options in my book make it an absolute winner as well. Concert For George doesn't even have a 5.1 option and again, the Dolby ATMOS mix is encoded at a VERY low level. Drat! If you don't have the Craft Recordings Concert for George 2 RBCD/2 BD~V set GRAB IT. Spectacular package and very highly recommended.
Similar threads
