Almen
500 Club - QQ All-Star
Yes, it is wonderful music and sonically pure, but this is a surround sound forum, and the mix is strictly audience/ambience. There is no music in the rears other than reverb, and to me this kills the deal as a surround title.
You have every right to your opinion, I just think's that it's a bit narrow to dismiss a huge part of the surround titles that exist as "non-surround". If there is sound in the rears, it is surround.
I have classical records with the ambience of the hall in the rears, and for me it is magic to be transported to the actual event. For me, there are good and bad mixes of all kinds, but there is no principle for how it should be mixed.