Listening to Now (In Surround) - Volume 2

QuadraphonicQuad

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Moloko.jpg

Moloko - Statues (Poll)

Matt Lawrence has already won me over in track 1 "Familiar Feeling" with the transition from centre to phantom centre vocals.

Love it when mixes take full advantage of the front-stage width control they have.

(Partly because it validates my insistence on matching left/centre/right!)
 
B2F70C3B-9027-4F83-BCBA-3A7C6F0DF4B2.jpeg


Henry Purcell: Oh! lead me to some peaceful gloom; Dido’s Lament
John Bennet: Venus’ Birds
Barbara Strozzi: Lamento (Lagrimemie), L’Eraclito amoroso
Claudia Sessa: Occhi io vissi di voi
Francesca Caccini: Lasciatemi qui solo
Lucrezia Vizzana: O magnum mysterium
Anonymous: The Willow Song; O death, rock me asleep

Ruby Hughes (soprano)
Mime Yamahiro Brinkmann (cello)
Jonas Nordberg (lute)
 
I see that Naxos also has this same recording in SACD format.

Generally speaking I find the DTS of DVDA superior in channel separation but I also appreciate that SACD might have other qualities?

Any thoughts/experience on this issue?
The Naxos SACDs have a stereo layer based on the 24/48 original recording (no stereo on the DVD-As, just a downmix), but the DVD-Audio releases are essentially the master file, while the SACDs are a conversion to DSD that may have minor degradation. In practice they're pretty similar.
 
*also discovered this BASF Spanish SQ LP from1974 while doing a bit of research (anyone heard it?)
https://www.discogs.com/Escolania-D...garra-Pergolesi-Missa-Romana/release/10839654

That looks very interesting and could be awesome in Quad. Pergolesi’s Missa Romana is for 2 or 4 choirs. If it‘s 4 choirs, the Quad recording might have one in each corner. Even if it’s 2 choirs, they might be separated in the front and rear channels. I believe the back of the album sleeve says 2 choirs and soloists. The photo shows the performers in a typical arrangement together in front of the stage, so it is difficult to determine whether they tried to make a discrete surround mix or only an ambient one. At any rate, Pergolesi’s Missa for 4 choirs certainly is a prime candidate for a surround recording.

0F9B7B04-66DF-4B28-A749-DE6B625A1191.jpeg


I found an old review of the LP version. Scroll down to pages 110 and 111.

https://worldradiohistory.com/Archi...iFI-Stereo/70s/HiFi-Stereo-Review-1974-01.pdf
The reviewer doesn’t mention the Quad mix, which is a pity because elsewhere the magazine is full of information about Quad. There is even a discussion of the 70s oil shortage having an impact on sourcing PVC for records, especially Quad. (On page 54).
 
Last edited:
That looks very interesting and could be awesome in Quad. Pergolesi’s Missa Romana is for 2 or 4 choirs. If it‘s 4 choirs, the Quad recording might have one in each corner. Even if it’s 2 choirs, they might be separated in the front and rear channels. I believe the back of the album sleeve says 2 choirs and soloists. The photo shows the performers in a typical arrangement together in front of the stage, so it is difficult to determine whether they tried to make a discrete surround mix or only an ambient one. At any rate, Pergolesi’s Missa for 4 choirs certainly is a prime candidate for a surround recording.

View attachment 67620

I found an old review of the LP version. Scroll down to pages 110 and 111.

https://worldradiohistory.com/Archi...iFI-Stereo/70s/HiFi-Stereo-Review-1974-01.pdf
The reviewer doesn’t mention the Quad mix, which is a pity because elsewhere the magazine is full of information about Quad. There is even a discussion of the 70s oil shortage having an impact on sourcing PVC for records, especially Quad. (On page 54).
Nice research Lute!

If you do a search here on the QQ for that label “Harmonia Mundi” plenty of posts pop up (a gold mine of info!)

I followed up just now with a discogs search for the label and Quadraphonic and came up with these results. I’m not much of a classical guy, so don’t know if there’s anything uniquely special or of any significance to glean from this bunch-

https://www.discogs.com/search/?q=Harmonia+Mundi+Quadraphonic&type=all&page=1
 
Nice research Lute!

If you do a search here on the QQ for that label “Harmonia Mundi” plenty of posts pop up (a gold mine of info!)

I followed up just now with a discogs search for the label and Quadraphonic and came up with these results. I’m not much of a classical guy, so don’t know if there’s anything uniquely special or of any significance to glean from this bunch-

https://www.discogs.com/search/?q=Harmonia+Mundi+Quadraphonic&type=all&page=1
Really interesting! Are these discrete at all? Harmonia Mundi is still around, and they've had some great SACD releases - I'm thinking especially of the Tokyo String Quartet releases - but I don't get the sense they were much interested in reissuing their quads.

(also, maybe this and preceding posts should be moved to the classical thread?)
 
Nice research Lute!

If you do a search here on the QQ for that label “Harmonia Mundi” plenty of posts pop up (a gold mine of info!)

I followed up just now with a discogs search for the label and Quadraphonic and came up with these results. I’m not much of a classical guy, so don’t know if there’s anything uniquely special or of any significance to glean from this bunch-

https://www.discogs.com/search/?q=Harmonia+Mundi+Quadraphonic&type=all&page=1
That list is making me drool like a pup! 🐶💦 There is an nice selection of delicacies from the Baroque and even Renaissance eras. About the surround mix, though, my hunch is that they are mostly ambient. I would love to be proved wrong.

On a side note, I remember a while back that you enjoyed “Musique and Sweet Poetrie - Kirkby, Lindberg”

EF301FC3-BBA9-4B89-ABF2-66CB2CD44C01.jpeg


If you’re interested in another album in a similar vein, you might also like “Heroines of Love and Loss - Hughes, Brinkmann, Nordberg”. Hughes has an equally lovely voice and this one includes a baroque cello. The selection of music has a nice, varied arrangement. Perhaps the best part is the recording and the venue. Just as with Kirkby/Lindberg, the air and space of the recording venue is captured exquisitely.

DF9B32D2-5BE0-4ED9-B6F2-860426AF4023.jpeg
 
Back
Top