No poll for this but this seems like the best place...
Dan Gibson/ Solitudes - Ocean Surf SACD
Mix: 3/5: Well, it's real, so you can't complain. But it's not necessarily realistic. Maybe the front is not very wide and the rears are too wide - the sound is not a continuous flow but instead separate corners.
Sound: 3/5: Doesn't sound amazing. I'm sure it's well recorded, but I suppose crashing waves do sound a bit rough and muffled.
Music: 2/5: Obviously, I knew what I was getting. It is very repetitive and not meant to be exciting. But it's nice to have some surround sound to enjoy but half ignore while doing other things.
Weighted score: 3*3 + 3*2 + 2*1 = 17/30 = 5.66/10 = 6/10