SPOTLIGHT The classical music general discussion thread
- Thread starter windhoek
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
4-earredwonder
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 15,312
An Excellent album superbly recorded.
Read the Review at HRAudio.net
HRAudio.net - Adams: Doctor Atomic Symphony, Short Ride in a Fast Machine, Harmonielehre - Oundjian
High Resolution Audio
www.hraudio.net
The rational view would be that two versions of any piece is enough, but here we are.
4-earredwonder
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 15,312
Kal Rubinson
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
I downloaded this one to find out. The performance is OK, to be sure, but the sound is not competitive with the MTT. You only have to listen to the opening minute of "Short Ride" to realize that you can barely hear any of the woodwinds that are so clear and delectable on the MTT.
Last edited:
Kal Rubinson
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
I read it and I must say that in comparing this with the MTT and saying "Direct comparison between the two recordings does marginally favour the latter" is an unfortunate use of the word "marginally." OTOH, I do agree with his later statement that "Nevertheless, the Chandos trump card for many listeners could well be the inclusion on this disc of Adams's 'Dr. Atomic Symphony' making its first appearance on SACD. "An Excellent album superbly recorded.
Read the Review at HRAudio.net
HRAudio.net - Adams: Doctor Atomic Symphony, Short Ride in a Fast Machine, Harmonielehre - Oundjian
High Resolution Audiowww.hraudio.net
This week's discounted new title at eClassical is Allan Pettersson's 12th Symphony, part of Christian Lindberg's cycle with the Norrkoping Symphony.
Is anybody here a Pettersson fan? If so, can you "testify" (about his symphonic music and/or about these recordings on BIS)? I've done some quick Google-reading, but otherwise I don't know the first thing about him.
www.eclassical.com
Is anybody here a Pettersson fan? If so, can you "testify" (about his symphonic music and/or about these recordings on BIS)? I've done some quick Google-reading, but otherwise I don't know the first thing about him.
eClassical - Allan Pettersson - Symphony No. 12 ‘The Dead in the Square’
In more ways than one, the Twelfth Symphony forms an exception in Allan Pettersson’s output. When he agreed to compose a work for the 500th anniversary of Uppsala University,
halbroome
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
New surround SACD from Tacet! Seems they can do no wrong, so I guess I'm buying it 
. Oh, who am I fooling, I have all their others
. Oh, who am I fooling, I have all their others Good to know they're still active. (I hope this shows up at ImportCDs soon, though. Direct from Tacet, it's €30 shipped to the US.)New surround SACD from Tacet! Seems they can do no wrong, so I guess I'm buying it
View attachment 62042
Last edited:
Kal Rubinson
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
I am going to be a complainer: Aside from the surround immersion, is there any reason to acquiring yet more versions of these familiar pieces and from comparatively minor artists?New surround SACD from Tacet! Seems they can do no wrong, so I guess I'm buying it
View attachment 62042
For some of us, the reason is precisely the surround immersion! (I know that's emphatically not your thing...)
But as it happens, the 9th is also a case of a Shostakovich symphony I don't have in a performance by a more prominent orchestra. For the 5th, I'll probably stick with Ormandy and Honeck.
halbroome
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
While I played classical piano in my youth, my later teen years, college, and onward involved rock of all sorts. Surround sound brought me back into listening to classical, so I have no non-surround classical (!) previous to the surround ones. So this is rather fresh for me!
Unless I'm misunderstanding Vocalion's website, there may a couple new titles for classical.
Kal Rubinson
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
Granted but I gather there is no reason for me to want to hear it.
ubertrout
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2011
- Messages
- 1,616
It is fair to point out that there's been a lot of Shostakovich 5ths on SACD: HRAudio.net - Recordings. And I feel like most people have the Kitajenko cycle, and other recordings as well. I'm intrigued but the way Shostakovich can be really percussive has the potential to be kind of unpleasant in a active surround setting.
I count 5!
All great ones. Very excited to hear more Boulez. As for the others: Kal's point about still more versions of familiar pieces (not minor conductor/ensembles) applies. But I'll snap 'em up anyway.
Does anyone know who the mixers are on any of these?
[Edit: partial answers below.]
Last edited:
Boulez-Falla:
Mixed by Ray Moore.
Boulez-Ravel:
Mixed by Ray Moore.
Bernstein-Stravinsky:
Mixed by Larry Keyes.
Stokowski-Beethoven:
Mixer unknown?
Stokowski-Mahler:
Mixer unknown?
Mixed by Ray Moore.
Boulez-Ravel:
Mixed by Ray Moore.
Bernstein-Stravinsky:
Mixed by Larry Keyes.
Stokowski-Beethoven:
Mixer unknown?
Stokowski-Mahler:
Mixer unknown?
Last edited:
