No I haven't.....I didn't realize I had to click "view results"....that's different. I have this one, only I don't know if the one I bought is the ultimate edition.
HiRez Poll Tomita - PLANETS ULTIMATE EDITION (SACD)
- Thread starter JonUrban
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
Frogmort
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
I prefer the actual classical Planets, but this does have some hard-core surround. Not much bass, or high-fidelity, but solid surround info.
ogrequad
Senior Member
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2013
- Messages
- 277
A quick question for those of you have both the Planets and the Pictures at an Exhibition SACDs:
I recently bought Pictures and I absolutely love it...Crazy, crazy surround action and it's also one of my favorite classical pieces (which is why I bought it first over Planets). That said, Planets seems to be rated a bit higher than Pictures in the QQ poll, and I'm wondering if that's a matter of personal preference in terms of the music or if, indeed, the Planets mix/fidelity is an improvement over Pictures. Anyone have an opinion/thought on this?
I'm debating about how much I need to own Planets and whether Pictures will satisfy my Tomita surround needs for the moment...Considering that I've spent quite a bit of cash on surround releases lately (Bitches Brew arrived today!!), I'm not sure I have the disposable income to drop another $25...but I will if I can be convinced that Planets is the one to get!!
I recently bought Pictures and I absolutely love it...Crazy, crazy surround action and it's also one of my favorite classical pieces (which is why I bought it first over Planets). That said, Planets seems to be rated a bit higher than Pictures in the QQ poll, and I'm wondering if that's a matter of personal preference in terms of the music or if, indeed, the Planets mix/fidelity is an improvement over Pictures. Anyone have an opinion/thought on this?
I'm debating about how much I need to own Planets and whether Pictures will satisfy my Tomita surround needs for the moment...Considering that I've spent quite a bit of cash on surround releases lately (Bitches Brew arrived today!!), I'm not sure I have the disposable income to drop another $25...but I will if I can be convinced that Planets is the one to get!!
kap'n krunch
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
my opinion is that there is no going wrong with ANY of Tomita's Quad releases..just sayin'
MrSmithers
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
I have both and I have to say I do prefer the Planets. They are of a very similar style and both very good but there is more going on in The Planets. I do also prefer the music so maybe slightly biased. I'm sure you wouldn't regret getting the Planets if you like Pictures. The great thing is they are both still available on SACD.
kap'n krunch
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
my all time fave is the Debussy one(s)
This is the only 10 I have given out (so far). It really is sensational! Can't remember where I got it, sorry, probably Amazon. Last Christmas I played it for a friend who is rarely impressed. He was impressed
After Planets and Clair de Lune, Which one do I follow?
windhoek
The Phoolosopher
The Tale of Genji is more like traditional Japanese music with narration telling the tale of Genji. I doubt it'll be a hit with many but I like it. It makes good use of surround as you'd expect from Tomita. Oh, and it's a 2-SACD release as it's too long to fit on one disc. The best thing to do is listen to more of his music on Youtube to get a feel for each and any albums you're thinking of buying.
windhoek
The Phoolosopher
damn that bot is a piece of a$$!
more seriously, are these Japanese Tomita SACDs out of print now?
i snoozed. i loozed
windhoek
The Phoolosopher
damn that bot is a piece of a$$!
more seriously, are these Japanese Tomita SACDs out of print now?
i snoozed. i loozed
I don't know the answer to that I'm afraid but as far as I can tell, they're all still available to buy online so I don't think there's any need for anyone to press the panic buy-button just yet. Oh, and damn those pesky bots!
Received yesterday Tenrankai no E (Pictures at an Exhibition). Fantastic surround mix!,
Just got this one. I voted 10. Great music and surround mix. I have the quad on q8, and there are a few differences in instruments and surround mix. Not a lot, both the original quad mix and this surround mix are excellent, i vote a 10 on both, but i do prefer the quad mix just a little better. Hopefully DV will give us the quad mix on sacd.
The56Kid
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
Finally did so, Mike!
After much prevarication, mainly over the cost for Japanese discs in the UK, I decided to buy this from Amazon UK at £31. I left the product page open on my PC for a couple of days went back to buy and, imagine my surprise, Amazon had reduced it £29 so obviously went for it. And today Amazon UK have changed the price again, now £27!! 
I have voted this a 10. I really like the music - it's Gustav Holst so what's not to like and I know this well in its original orchestral version. Tomita's style reminds me a lot of the late great Keith Emerson so there is another positive and the surround presentation is exactly why I have 5.1 system (OK this is 4.0 and is absolutely awesome) There are very few mixes that are so totally joined up with a full soundstage between all speakers. As a result I have now ordered his Pictures At An Exhibition Ultimate SACD from CD Japan. I have had the CD-4 vinyl since it first emerged so am really looking forward to this SACD. I am also enjoying Amin Bhatia's Interstellar Suite which definitely comes from the same stable. Aren't we lucky to have such fantastic music presented so brilliantly?!!
I have voted this a 10. I really like the music - it's Gustav Holst so what's not to like and I know this well in its original orchestral version. Tomita's style reminds me a lot of the late great Keith Emerson so there is another positive and the surround presentation is exactly why I have 5.1 system (OK this is 4.0 and is absolutely awesome) There are very few mixes that are so totally joined up with a full soundstage between all speakers. As a result I have now ordered his Pictures At An Exhibition Ultimate SACD from CD Japan. I have had the CD-4 vinyl since it first emerged so am really looking forward to this SACD. I am also enjoying Amin Bhatia's Interstellar Suite which definitely comes from the same stable. Aren't we lucky to have such fantastic music presented so brilliantly?!!
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
