Sadly, although not sounding entirely upmixed it may as well have been.
I know Silverline have a bad reputation, but they have also released some true surround stuff...
You can barely hear the surrounds, and putting an ear close to them sounds like a quiet reverbed version of the front. When I switched out the front LR pair, the centre channel seemed to be carrying everything but some backing vocals that appeared in the rears, but also appear in the front pair. This mix, including assistants, is credited to three people.
Not recommended!
I know Silverline have a bad reputation, but they have also released some true surround stuff...
You can barely hear the surrounds, and putting an ear close to them sounds like a quiet reverbed version of the front. When I switched out the front LR pair, the centre channel seemed to be carrying everything but some backing vocals that appeared in the rears, but also appear in the front pair. This mix, including assistants, is credited to three people.
Not recommended!