Fixing Rumours 5.1: Out of phase center channel of "Go Your Own Way" and out of phase LFE channel

QuadraphonicQuad

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

Joined
Nov 26, 2022
Messages
14
Location
Seattle
Hello! I have recently found that the center channel of Fleetwood Mac's "Go Your Own Way" off the DVD-A release of Rumours is out of phase with the rest of the music, and the LFE channel is out of phase with the rest of the mix.

The center channel appears to be around 2,880 samples too early (at 96kHz), and gives much of what it is shared between the center and front two channels a tube-like, double-tracked quality to them, especially the vocals. This I feel especially ruins the vitriol of Buckingham's vocals. The LFE as well seems to be out of phase across the album, arriving 2,049 samples early for "Go Your Own Way" specifically, and 392 or so samples late for the rest of the album (at 96kHz).

To show the difference, linked here are four 26-second snippets of "Go Your Own Way", as follows:
Keep in mind that the LFE is not included in the first two examples. (Note that I am sharing these links for the purposes of critique rather than piracy, which is why I cut them to 26 seconds.) I also noticed issues with other surround sound mixes as well, which I hope to post about soon!
 

ar surround

2K Club - QQ Super Nova
QQ Supporter
Joined
Apr 3, 2010
Messages
4,358
Location
New Joisey
Ah ha! I can never make it through the 5.1 of this song, and I often skip it altogether. Perhaps your discovery of phase issues is the reason why. You provide a nice description of what it sounds like, but my summary description is that it sounds like shit. :poop:

Good find!
 

ssully

2K Club - QQ Super Nova
Since 2002/2003
Joined
Jul 2, 2003
Messages
3,538
Location
in your face
Let's see, for CD-rate audio, 1 sample = 1/44,000 th of a second. That's 22 micro seconds, far below audibilty for latency. ~400 times that is still just shy of 9 milliseconds -- latency that is on the bare edge of audibility. For the DVD audio where the SR is 96,000 /sec obviously the number will be more than twice as low. So is that LFE latency really a problem?

There's a better case for correcting the 2K sample @ 96kHz (~21 milliseconds) latency of the C channel
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2022
Messages
14
Location
Seattle
Let's see, for CD-rate audio, 1 sample = 1/44,000 th of a second. That's 22 micro seconds, far below audibilty for latency. ~400 times that is still just shy of 9 milliseconds -- latency that is on the bare edge of audibility. For the DVD audio where the SR is 96,000 /sec obviously the number will be more than twice as low. So is that LFE latency really a problem?

There's a better case for correcting the 2K sample @ 96kHz (~21 milliseconds) latency of the C channel
I appreciate the criticism! Wouldn't the latency audibly affect the bass production in the subwoofer, though (assuming, of course, your speakers aren't built to playback those frequencies)?
 

Cheezmo

1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
Joined
Jun 5, 2011
Messages
1,086
Location
Texas

ssully

2K Club - QQ Super Nova
Since 2002/2003
Joined
Jul 2, 2003
Messages
3,538
Location
in your face
I appreciate the criticism! Wouldn't the latency audibly affect the bass production in the subwoofer, though (assuming, of course, your speakers aren't built to playback those frequencies)?
Like I said, at such a small latency between LFE and the rest, it is questionable whether it is audible. I see figures quoted ranging from 6 ms to 10 ms as the minimum audible. The LFE latency at 96khz SR that you are noting amounts to ~4 ms.

The Center vs rest latency you report, however, is certainly above those minima.
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2022
Messages
14
Location
Seattle
Like I said, at such a small latency between LFE and the rest, it is questionable whether it is audible. I see figures quoted ranging from 6 ms to 10 ms as the minimum audible. The LFE latency at 96khz SR that you are noting amounts to ~4 ms.

The Center vs rest latency you report, however, is certainly above those minima.
Hmm... Alright! Good to know! Thanks again for your thoughts!
 
Top