Please post your comments, thoughts and observations.......
I find most of the disc to have a horrible, muddy sound and the vocals are horrible on the majority of the tracks. Didn't find the mix inventive or to have added any extra punch to the music aswell. I grew up with this album during my last years at school so was really wanting this to sound great as I like the music on the disc quite a lot. But to me this is an SACD done badly. Can't imagine tape sounding any worse.
4/10
This is one of the few discs in the HiRez poll that has votes of every value except '1'. What a wide range of votes. I wonder if, as someone noted above, that there were actually two versions of this disc.
Also, I notice that this disc is being offered on Amazon for $450+!!!! Yikes
It's been a while since I heard this, and I never put in my own score, so this got a 3 out of 10 for reasons already stated. This is "big stereo" to the core, and not even "good big stereo" like WYWH was.
To me, the obvious candidate for a definite "1" has to be the complete dogs dinner that Harry Malin made of "Station to Station".
Bloody awful mix, and the worst I have ever heard, bar none - and this is one of my all-time top 10 favourire albums (STS, not the Oasis one)