PC for Multichannel Music Playback - What's your Setup?

QuadraphonicQuad

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I tried something new last week: I read that the $35 Raspberry Pi can output hi-rez multichannel via HDMI, so I ordered one. With power supply and case, the total cost was just barely under $50, so it wasn't too horrific a gamble. I installed OpenELEC (a stripped down Linux that boots directly into Kodi/XMBC) and...no.

Feeding it "The Endless River" resulted in the receiver saying it was indeed getting 5.1 at 24/96. Although I didn't do anything that would make me absolutely sure, I believe the signals were going to the correct speakers. That's the good news. The bad news is that the sound was littered with dropouts and completely unlistenable. It looks like the CPU, pegged at 100%, just can't keep up with the FLAC decoding.

I re-encoded a couple files from FLAC 8 down to FLAC 5 and the results were better, but still nowhere near good enough. If I have time, I may test with FLAC 0 just out of curiosity, but that's a real waste of storage space and possibly network bandwidth as well.

Locating the files on a network drive or on the internal MicroSD card made no difference.

Typically, I had been considering buying one of those little boxes for months but didn't finally pull the trigger until Wednesday. Because reality is little more than a plot to annoy me, I woke up this morning to the news that an updated Pi is coming with twice the RAM and a quad core processor...for the same $35 price! Maybe that will work.

You can find all kinds of claims out there from people swearing that their Pi can play 1080p video with multichannel audio, but I can find no evidence on my end that such a thing is even remotely possible. I couldn't even get it to play crappy downloaded porn--oops, I mean religious music videos--without trouble.
 
One positive about the Pi is that it worked just fine as a server when I tested it to feed music to the Oppo via DLNA or UPNP or whatever it's called this week. But of course that does not result in gapless playback.

Perhaps this setup would work with a newer Oppo with USB DAC, though I can't test that myself.
 
Locating the files on a network drive or on the internal MicroSD card made no difference.

WiFi or 100Mbps Ethernet could be a problem? Some MicroSD cards are slow too. (Just a thought).

There is a bunch of low cost quad core boxes coming including 4K Video capabilities so you are onto the right thing.

I couldn't go back to discs now.

Some people reporting these are ok:
http://www.solid-run.com/products/cubox-i-mini-computer/

And this looks interesting:
http://www.cloudmedia.com/products/open-hour/chameleon
 
WiFi or 100Mbps Ethernet could be a problem? Some MicroSD cards are slow too. (Just a thought).

I figured it might be the network as well, so I copied a few tracks onto the card. Still didn't work. The card is a very new class 10 Sandisk, so I hope I'm OK there.

There is a bunch of low cost quad core boxes coming including 4K Video capabilities so you are onto the right thing.

I couldn't go back to discs now.

Some people reporting these are ok:
http://www.solid-run.com/products/cubox-i-mini-computer/

And this looks interesting:
http://www.cloudmedia.com/products/open-hour/chameleon

I'll have to check those out, thanks! I've also ordered the new quad core Pi, though I have no idea when it will actually ship.
 
FYI - I tried a friends Raspberry Pi with some variant of XMBC and got similar results.... A couple of years ago..
 
The Solid Runs (my link in my previous post) look like an interesting inexpensive option and suitable for non-geeks it can be ordered with XBMC/Kodi Media Player software pre-installed. All you need to do is connect to your receiver and a LAN or USB to your music (external USB drive is pretty simple).
 
The Solid Runs (my link in my previous post) look like an interesting inexpensive option and suitable for non-geeks it can be ordered with XBMC/Kodi Media Player software pre-installed. All you need to do is connect to your receiver and a LAN or USB to your music (external USB drive is pretty simple).

I've ordered their top of the line one for $139...now I just need to wait for the shipping from Israel!

In the meantime, I did get my hands on one of the newer quad-core Raspberry Pis. It doesn't drop out as often as the older one and the CPU is nowhere near maxed out when playing back, but the damned thing still doesn't *really* work for multichannel FLAC. I tried storing the music on the SD card, on a USB stick, on the network via Samba and on the network via NFS. Same results no matter what: Great multichannel hi-rez sound...until the next dropout.
 
I noticed you saying you use DvDfab as your Decryptor but hasn't the government through court order shut down DVD Fab. Or is it if you have a copy you can still use it but they were forced to stop selling the product. Also would you have any suggestions on a good Blu Ray dycrypter.
 
You can see whats going on with the waveform seekbar (under the cover art)...
View attachment 16837

& with the spectogram under the display info...
View attachment 16838

It shows all channels...

Hey Lizard....how you get that nifty looking console at the bottom of the screenshot? Where it says TRACK 15, elapsed time, etc.....I like the clean look...
 
So, when I download a file, it goes to my download folder. I go there, click on it and it asks me what I want to use to open the file. usually when that happens, somehow it's file type not supported by my Windows 8.

You need 7zip or winrar to open the file, the real files are wrapped in the zip file. You can find 7zip here: http://www.7-zip.org


After you installed it just right-click on the zip file and in the context menu 7zip/extract here. (I don't know why this is underlined :mad:@:)
 

Man, I must be a dope - I just don't understand....I see the "skin" file in the 7zip program...but I still don't understand what to do with it there....I can click extract I guess....which I did...but it sure didn't change or add anything to foobar.
 
You have to install it within Foobar: File/preferences/components-> istall and then look for the file:

Install.jpg
 
Let's start again, after you installed 7zip you rightclick on the darkone 4 zip file (don't use open with 7zip) then in the contextmenu go to 7zip/extract here like this:

7zip.jpg

and after you extracted the files from the zip file:see instructions textfile thats also extracted, you can forget about my previous post because this one installs different then normal components from Foobar, sorry about that.
 
I'm sorry Jan - no matter what I do, it never looks, or takes me where you show above. Obviously, I just don't know how to make the damn 7zip work. I'll just give up for now....too complicated for my small brain. :)
 
Back
Top