Being a pretty big Peter Gabriel fan I ordered a couple of discs from CircuitCity including UP which won't be released now til June. Anyway, I picked up "Shaking the Tree" today as it was on sale and wanted to compare it to the remastered cd which I own. If you are a fan of P.G. and don't have the remastered versions I would suggest buying them. However if you already own the remastered versions I would advise NOT getting the SACD versions. I did an A-B test of the two and at least on "Shaking the Tree", I prefered the cd version over the sacd on every song. The sacd sounds very good, but at least on my system the cd sound better. The sacd sounded a bit muffled in comparison. The highs were brighter with the remastered cd and the subwoofer kicked better as well. The difference is similar to taking the grills off your speakers. Also the advantage to the cds is that the sacds are not hybrids. So in summary I would not invest in the sacd remasters if you already own the cd remasters. "Up" is of course an entirely different matter as it will be multichannel.