Well, that's up to you, but Lucpac, a member there who is quite an authority on all things The Who has been contributing generously to that thread and has posted lots of good info on the mastering sources for much of the new comp. Believe me, he would have dismissed it right out of hand had it been another shoddy cheap-jack comp. There's some interesting things going on over at The Who camp lately, as in all the recent I-tunes and HDtracks additions with shockingly good sonics. Who fans all over are a-buzzin'. I also bought it and concur with the generally favorable opinions. It IS a comp though, so nobody is going to like every track or it's mastering, but all in all it's surprisingly good, plus it has the new song on it. It was on sale at Best Buy in a collector's box with a t-shirt for $9.99 the last few weeks so at that price it was a no-brainer for many of us that might not have picked it up. I'm actually very glad I did.