I agree. Make It Big in Atmos is the real deal. "Wake Me Up Before You GoGo" and "Freedom" are kinda thin and brittle, and drenched in layers of reverb, exactly like the original versions. But, otherwise, the rest of the album opens up and I think it is a sonic delight. Plus, the boatload of bonus tracks is the icing on the cake. Fantastic, at least musically, is not too, IMO. The Atmos mix is great, but the songwriting is not on the same level as Make It Big. It's an album that clearly suffers from the dreaded "sophomore jinx" and surely marked the beginning of the end for the duo. I consider Make It Big to be definitive and an excellent addition to my library. I can't say the same for Fantastic.