I tried. But I don't want to get into a back and forth myself.
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=714734
:-jon
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=714734
:-jon
Some of my favorite mixes are from Scheiner and I have read the criticism over at AVSForums but declined to participate. One person's opinion is just that and as far as I know, there will never be a definitive way to mix stereo that all can agree upon, much less a definitive approach to surround mixes that all will agree is best. "Blood on the Tracks" was my first awareness of who Scheiner is and I can't think of a single misfire from him, although there must be at least a couple.
Chris
I have heard some of the REM ones he did are so so, but not being a fan of REM I haven't heard them. Blood On the Tracks was done with Phil Ramone (IIRC), and it's a lighter touch than the usual ES fare.
I have heard some of the REM ones he did are so so, but not being a fan of REM I haven't heard them. Blood On the Tracks was done with Phil Ramone (IIRC), and it's a lighter touch than the usual ES fare.
I tried. But I don't want to get into a back and forth myself.
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=714734
:-jon
i have all the REM's except Monster and I find them all well done. I tend to think that because REM the band doesn't seem to get much love online these days, scheiner's fine work on these perhaps gets overlooked.
Elliot Scheiner rocks! Anyone who is even remotely into surround-sound should appreciate everything he has done in the arena. Are there really people out there trashing him? Sorry, I won't visit the AVSForum for the very reasons already described. I would take any ES complaints there with a very large grain of salt.
You would do well not to go there. I did and I am afraid if I do post it will definately be the last time there.
Enter your email address to join: