..
funny thing is that I thought I had that one in my cart at amazon...but on closer inspection it's not the same item...yours has 2 discs and THIS ONE but this one IS blu ray audio...that's why one disc..
What's the latest Multichannel SACD or DVD-A added to your pile? - Volume 2
- Thread starter JonUrban
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
funny thing is that I thought I had that one in my cart at amazon...but on closer inspection it's not the same item...yours has 2 discs and THIS ONE but this one IS blu ray audio...that's why one disc..
Laird_Williams
Well-known Member
Have had several spins of Gavin Harrison's "Cheating the Polygraph" since it arrived.
I have to qualify this - I have spent many years listening to wind ensembles, drum corps, and big bands. I am also a huge prog-rock fan, and Porcupine Tree is high on my list of faves. Soo...
1) The tunes are barely recognizable. If you are familiar with the PT catalog, then you will be able to JUST pull the originals from the presentation. This is not a criticism. In the same way that many romantic era pieces borrow in a subtle way from the composer's native folk tradition, this album borrows from PT. It is recognizable without being overly-derivative.
2) The musicianship on this album is second-to-nothing. The rhythmic complexity and percussion work is outstanding. We should all expect that given whose name is on that album. But the FAT FAT FAT jazz harmonies and horn playing are just outstanding. Put the percussion, rhythmic complexity, harmony, and brilliant execution together in one place and you get an exemplary album.
3) The mix is excellent - both in surround and stereo. The dynamic range is there. The detail is high. The separation and balance are there.
If you've never liked, or even listen to Porcupine Tree - ignore that fact. Give this album a spin. It is unique in every way imaginable - and delightful. If you ARE familiar with the originals of the tunes on this album then be prepared to have your mind blown.
An alternative title might be "Not the Benny Goodman Orchestra". Not that I dislike Benny Goodman. But if you think of Benny Goodman or something like that when you think big band, think again and give this one a listen - on iTunes if you have to.
I have to qualify this - I have spent many years listening to wind ensembles, drum corps, and big bands. I am also a huge prog-rock fan, and Porcupine Tree is high on my list of faves. Soo...
1) The tunes are barely recognizable. If you are familiar with the PT catalog, then you will be able to JUST pull the originals from the presentation. This is not a criticism. In the same way that many romantic era pieces borrow in a subtle way from the composer's native folk tradition, this album borrows from PT. It is recognizable without being overly-derivative.
2) The musicianship on this album is second-to-nothing. The rhythmic complexity and percussion work is outstanding. We should all expect that given whose name is on that album. But the FAT FAT FAT jazz harmonies and horn playing are just outstanding. Put the percussion, rhythmic complexity, harmony, and brilliant execution together in one place and you get an exemplary album.
3) The mix is excellent - both in surround and stereo. The dynamic range is there. The detail is high. The separation and balance are there.
If you've never liked, or even listen to Porcupine Tree - ignore that fact. Give this album a spin. It is unique in every way imaginable - and delightful. If you ARE familiar with the originals of the tunes on this album then be prepared to have your mind blown.
An alternative title might be "Not the Benny Goodman Orchestra". Not that I dislike Benny Goodman. But if you think of Benny Goodman or something like that when you think big band, think again and give this one a listen - on iTunes if you have to.
For what it's worth this review says the sacd sounds better than the blu-ray:
http://audaud.com/2014/11/bach-six-brandenburg-concertos-stuttgart-ch-orch-tacet-audio-only-blu-ray/
Burning Shed lists this as a DVD-V. Is it really a DVD-A?
That was my very first Bach title that I got (the DVD-A edition), and I was hooked on the first listen. Before that I'd only ever heard just segments of the Brandenburgs, but it took me a long time to finally get one. Since then, I've found myself collecting different performances of them on DVD-A and SACD - I think I have seven now. If you can find a copy of Silverline Classics DualDisc edition performed by the Academy of St. James, I think you'd probably like that a lot as well.
A Trick Of The Tail - Genesis (Hybrid MultiCh SACD + 5.1 DVD-V).
That's it! The last of the Genesis SACDs on the shopping list! Yeay!
View attachment 18741
Glad you finally got this one as it's my favorite in the blue 1976-1982 box. I think this particular SACD is one of the rarer ones now.
I've never been able to find the Blue SACD box for anywhere approaching sensible coinage.. Yes, this is one of the rarer/pricier ones now.. grabbed it on Amazon UK marketplace the other day for £15! Hoorah!
colsky
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
Its an Audio DVD-V
I'm glad you didn't say "only a DVD-V"!! It may be, but its a damn fine disc all the same. In my humble opinion its in the "demo quality, every home should have one" category
@:
Lute
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
I know exactly how feel. The more I listen to classical music the more wonderful and meaningful it becomes. It is a fascinating and rewarding journey of endless discovery. And now in 4.0 and 5.1, my addiction and passion are in interstellar overdrive... to the stars and beyond...
:51banana:
I look forward to sharing our experiences with classical (and all) music with everyone here. :brew
I got this one just last month and it's wonderful. I like how each different concerto takes a different approach to the surround mix. I got the BluRay from importcds who had a good price.
I've never been able to find the Blue SACD box for anywhere approaching sensible coinage.. Yes, this is one of the rarer/pricier ones now.. grabbed it on Amazon UK marketplace the other day for £15! Hoorah!
I would think that the DVDs in those sets will become rare collector's items also, because of the interviews and performance footage that aren't being passed on to the blu-ray editions.
I think that was a poor decision...
That's crazy awesome! (Crazy cause of the price but awesome because it's a fine mix indeed!)
I still need to locate this one myself, but I don't want to pay the crazy prices it's fetching.
This is one (along with "Boys and Girls") that UMe need to reissue as HFPA Blu-Rays!
I agree, there are a few sacd's that deserve a price like this though and Avalon is one of them (so is Boys and Girls
).Here some prices on eBay
Good job!..That one is on my list...
I'm glad you didn't say "only a DVD-V"!! It may be, but its a damn fine disc all the same. In my humble opinion its in the "demo quality, every home should have one" category
Similar threads
