I just picked up the HD DVD. I needed to own enough of those discs to justify owning a player or get rid of the player and I decided to buy more discs after the format was removed from life support. It is a great reunion concert, my only complaint is Clapton and Bruce are a little out of sync when trying to harmonize, otherwise, these old guys did really well. I really think this HD DVD offers DVD quality audio only which wasn't uncommon for Warner so I hope Warner ups their game with the extra capacity and bitrate available with Blu-ray. This sounds great anyway so I won't replace it if Warner does offer a Dolby TrueHD version on Blu-ray in the future. My HD-A1 could only find stereo PCM and DTS 5.1 so I assume that is all that was offered here, no Dolby Digital.
I don't really think these three guys are going to ever do this again, so this was a must have for me. As an HD DVD concert disc, it gets an 8 from me but I don't guess I will vote here.
Chris