I went with an 8 and agonized a bit between that and a 9.
As I’ve been listening, I’ve wondered if 2023-me could have convinced 1982-me to sit down in front of a really good system to listen, despite not liking this style of music then. I always heard the singles on a cheap car stereo, cheap home system or cheap TV which certainly didn’t allow me to hear the music at its best.
But between the solid bass and rhythm guitar in Atmos, I’d like to think I could have appreciated it more if I had heard it this way back then.
One reason I went with an 8 is because I think it kind of poops out on the final songs. Maybe I’ll feel differently on further listens and up my score.
Also, the marking of beginning/ending of tracks on the Bluray makes ripping kind of strange. (Discussed in another thread.)
While not a major thing listening on the Bluray itself, I do listen to ripped versions of albums quite a bit. Hardly fatal, but stuff like this or the quieter Atmos levels we’ve talked about on other releases makes me feel like things are getting a little sloppy in ways that they shouldn’t. I did wonder if I’m being fair knocking it down for that.
I wish the Instrumental mix was in Atmos, but then I figured I could somehow turn off my center speaker... only to find I have no idea how to do that even after pouring through sites. The best I can do is turn the center speaker down a ways, but not completely off. (And I have no desire to just pull the wires out temporarily.)
But I’m listening to the Atmos now and even if I could totally disable the center, I would be hearing a bit of voice in the other speakers. A slightly different listening experience with downplayed vocals, though.
Despite my score of 8, I think that if you loved this album growing up, nothing here is going to make you love it less. You’ll probably love it even more that Wilson has worked his magic, and I can understand the 10s.